Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Anatomical Gifts - the gifts that keep giving …


(originally published May 22, 2009)

News Item:  "Natalie Cole, singer and daughter of Nat King Cole, received a kidney transplant on May 19, 2009 at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center in Los Angeles, California.  The kidney came from an anonymous donor who recently died.  Her family directed that her kidney be given to Natalie." 

I saw this headline and was reminded of a former client and friend, I'll call him Theodore (1), going through divorce and an early mid-life crisis, who adopted a New Age name and went off to live in various group communities.  While living in Boston, he heard about people who voluntary donate one of their kidneys to strangers in need, took inventory of his kidneys, found he had one to spare, and so agreed to donate one.  Not when he died.  While he was still living.  And so he signed up with a particular hospital, they found a compatible match from their waiting list of people who needed a kidney, and then performed the simultaneous surgery, removing one of my friend's healthy kidneys, and then inserting it in place of a failed kidney in the woman recipient.  To my knowledge, the surgery was a success, and both patients are living happily ever after.  In both cases, the donor made an "anatomical gift" of their body parts to a willing recipient. 

The first instance was a case of "directed donation":  the donor selects the person to receive the anatomical gift.  This is more common among family members - who are likely to be compatible for donations of this type.  It is rare that you see directed donations to strangers.  You see examples of directed donation with blood donations, such as parents to children, and among family members.  Because family members have shared genes, they typically are more compatible for other procedures such as bone marrow transplants used in treating certain cancers.  They also have that common bond of family and love, and so are more motivated to help their own child, brother or sister.  But as the example of Natalie Cole indicates, you can direct your donation to a particular stranger, if you are so inclined, and you are a compatible match to the person in need. 

The second example, my friend Theodore, was what is called an "altruistic donor":  the person who is willing to give up a piece of his anatomy, a spare organ, for the good it will do for others.  The sale of organs is prohibited, and so the motivation to take this step comes from deeper within the donor.  Those of us who regularly donate blood to the Red Cross are motivated in that sense.  This is altruistic donation:  we don't know where our blood is going, but we do so hoping that it does some good for someone in need.  My son, following my college tradition at Penn State, regularly donates his plasma:  the plasma center withdraws a pint of blood, centrifuges it to separate the red cells from the white, keeps the white, returns the red cells to the donor, and repeats the process one more time.  However, there is a mixed motivation here:  the plasma centers pay college students to do this; and the pay is pretty good for an hour of their time.  But it feels good to know that your plasma is going to someone in need.  I have signed up for the national marrow donor registry.  I did so after learning about Alexandra "Alex" Scott and her famous lemonade stand.  Alex, from Wynnewood, Pennsylvania, was diagnosed with neuroblastoma, a type of childhood cancer, before she had turned one.  At age four, she decided to take matters into her own hands, and opened up a lemonade stand on her front lawn, to raise money for cancer research.  Alex passed away at age 8 in 2004, but her lemonade stand has raised over $25 million to fight pediatric cancer.  On her website, I read about the National Marrow Donor Registry, and followed through, receiving a kit in the mail and sending off swabs of cheek tissue to be tested and added to the registry.  If this little girl could endure what she endured, and make such a significant contribution in her eight short years, then the least I could do would be to volunteer to try to be a match for some other little boy or girl in need.  

Blood regenerates.  Plasma regenerates.  Marrow regenerates.  There are other bodily parts that regenerate, and that are now being transplanted from living donors, including the lung, liver and pancreas.  A living donor is able to donate a portion of their liver to someone in need of a liver transplant.  The liver is the only organ that can regenerate and will grow back to nearly 100 % of its size in a short amount of time.  Then you can do it again!

And the latest idea in this field:  paired donors.  One altruistic donor is needed to start the ball rolling:  he or she gives the gift of life to a compatible stranger, who has lined up their spouse or other loved one to "match" the gift; that gift is given to another compatible stranger who is willing to again "match" the gift.  And on it goes.  According to the March 12 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine, to date the longest paired-donor kidney transplantation chain has involved 10 organ transplants.  Talk about a matching gift.  Ten lives saved as a result of one altruistic donor.

According to the national registry maintained by the Department of Health and Human Services, as of May 15, 2009, there are 102,118 people registered to receive an organ of some kind when a donor is found:  80% of those are for kidneys; 15% for livers; and then pancreas, hearts, lungs, intestines rounding out the list of need.  We all may need blood from time to time.  We or our loved ones, all may need plasma, or marrow.  We are relying on the generosity of altruistic donors in each of these cases.  We have a population of over 300 million in this country.  It makes the number of people who need an organ transplant, 102,118, look small by comparison.  No matter how altruistic we may be, we can't actually give our hearts to these people; but we can certainly use the motivation that comes from that part of us to consider what we can do for those in need, whether while living, or upon our death.  When reviewing your estate plan, think about that issue.  It might not be for everyone, but it might be for you.  And for the people who would benefit for such a generous gift. 

1.  Theodore:  gift of God

©2009  Douglas P. Humes

Saturday, March 27, 2010

A BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE NEW HEALTH CARE LAW


As mentioned in an earlier post, I went to my gym earlier in the week and found out that they were discontinuing offering the tanning bed to members, starting in May.  This was the first ripple from the new health care law - there will be a 10% tax on indoor tanning services, and so my gym is simply dropping the service rather than dealing with the administrative headaches of collecting and reporting the tax.  So, I have been digging around to try to separate the wheat from the chaff in the debate, and find out what else we can expect, and when we can expect it.  Obviously, I cannot capture the entire law and its ramifications in this article - the sea is so large and my boat is so small - but I have tried to distill out the essence.  So here goes:

2010     -No denial of coverage to children based on preexisting conditions. 
             -Children allowed to stay on their parent's insurance plans until age 26.
             -$250 rebate for Medicare beneficiaries who hit “donut hole" ($2,830 annual prescription drug limit)
            - Adults with pre-existing conditions eligible for temporary high-risk pool (superseded in 2014 by health care exchange program)
             -Insurers prohibited from charging co-pays or deductibles for preventive care and medical screenings on NEW insurance plans (existing plans grandfathered till 2018).
             -Insurers are prohibited from dropping policyholders when they get sick
             -New website at Dept. Health and Human Services will provide consumer insurance information for individuals and small businesses in all states

2011     Seniors in “donut hole" ($2,830 annual prescription drug limit) will receive a 50 percent discount on brand name drugs. 

2013      3.8% Medicare Payroll Tax on investment income (interest, dividends, annuities, royalties, capital gains and rents) for individuals who earn more than $200,000 annually and joint filers reporting more than $250,000.

2014     -Everyone must purchase health insurance or face a $695 annual fine; exemptions for financial hardship or religious beliefs
             -Subsidies to purchase insurance for individuals with income up to 400% of the poverty line.
             -Tax penalty ($2000 per employee) on employers (over 50 employees) who do not offer health insurance to their workers. 
             -Medicare Payroll withholding increases from 2.9% to 3.8% on earned income.
             -Qualifying medical expenses income tax deduction increases from 7.5% to 10%
             -No lifetime and annual limits on coverage 
             -No denial of coverage to anyone with preexisting conditions.
             -Exchanges created for small businesses to purchase coverage
             -States expand Medicaid to include childless adults.  Federal Government pays 100 percent of costs for covering newly eligible individuals through 2016. 

2018     -Insurance companies will pay a 40% excise tax on "Cadillac" high-end insurance plans worth over $27,500 for families ($10,200 for individuals). 
             -All insurance plans will provide coverage for preventive care and checkups without co-payment.

The official name of the Act is the "Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010" in the event you want to google it and look for particular provisions.  Certain provisions of the Act have already been challenged in court - the focus is the "individual mandate" - can the federal government order you to buy health insurance and fine you if you do not?  No legal scholars on either side suggest that the government cannot accomplish virtually all of what this new law proposes - the further regulation of health care and insurance - by passing the law and then raising taxes to pay for it.  However, the new law, while it raises certain taxes, avoids raising income taxes on "the middle class" to pay for the expanded coverage by instead requiring each individual to buy insurance.  The result is that this is not a "tax", but an "individual mandate".  That explanation is sufficient for some, and deficient for others.  The Supreme Court will eventually sort it all out.  

©2010  Douglas P. Humes 

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

The first ripples in the health care pool ...

I went to my gym this morning to swim.  There is a tanning bed there - but not for long.  It is being discontinued as of May 15th.  The new health care law puts a 10% tax on individuals receiving indoor tanning services.  The tax has to be explained, collected, reported, and the cost of the tax flows directly to the user - the price paid for the service must be increased.  Much easier for a gym like mine, offering it simply as an additional service, to discontinue it.   But what about a business set up solely for tanning?  Will all tanners continue to pay the higher price?  Basic economics principles say no - elasticity of demand as a function of price - and so use will decline, and the businesses on the margin will close.  The tax primarily affects female business owners, who own about two-thirds of tanning salons in the U.S.  Fewer businesses in the industry mean fewer suppliers and manufacturers.  A net loss of jobs at both the retail and wholesale level.  This provision is a tiny little piece of the entire bill - one sentence in the  thousands of pages, but already it has a ripple effect.  It is easy to see the loss here.  What is gained?  And that is the real question that is overlooked in the loud and angry debate - what will the actual effects of the bill be when the laws of economics and individual behavior kick in?  The only thing certain is that no one knows.  

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Florida AG and 12 other states file suit against new health care law


"Attorney General Bill McCollum today filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, U.S. Department of Treasury and the U.S. Department of Labor alleging the Health Care Reform bill signed into law by President Obama this morning is unconstitutional.  The bipartisan lawsuit was joined by 12 Attorneys General and is the first challenge of the new law.  ...The Attorneys General from South Carolina, Nebraska, Texas, Utah, Louisiana, Alabama, Colorado, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Washington, Idaho, and South Dakota joined Florida’s lawsuit, filed today in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Florida."  [source:  http://www.myfloridalegal.com/newsrel.nsf/newsreleases/2426DBDB65C843D7852576EF005DB3A4 ]

Here's a link to the actual complaint that was filed, for those few people who still like to read about the issues before taking sides:  


The interesting part will come after the answer has been filed and both sides file briefs, exploring the fault line between the rights of the States under the 10th amendment and the use of the Commerce Clause to justify the individual mandate.  

The 10th amendment:  "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

The Commerce Clause:  The United States Congress shall have power "To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes". 

In first year law school, we spent about half of the year in our Constitutional Law class looking at the evolution of the Commerce Clause, from its modest beginnings to basic interstate trade issues, to the New Deal and Franklin Roosevelt's Court Packing plan, and the "switch in time that saved nine," where two justices who had voted with the conservative court switched their votes and created a new majority which became more deferential to Acts of Congress.  The reach of the Commerce Clause broadened in the 1960's for use in attacking segregation in the South - and reached its peak when the Court found that the federal Civil Rights laws reached all the way in to the kitchen at Ollie's Barbecue, a family owned restaurant in Birmingham, Alabama, specializing in barbecued meats and homemade pies, because of "meat that it bought from a local supplier who had procured it from outside the State".  That was the commerce that was being regulated:  hot dogs and buns that "moved in commerce" and arrived at Ollie's Barbecue.  

It certainly led to the right result - seating and service for blacks in all restaurants in the South, but through the back door.  For those who are result driven, and don't care about the path traveled to get there, that is all that matters.  For those who view the Constitution as an agreement between the states and the federal government as to what rights they each have, and a check on government power, the use of the Commerce Clause as a trump card, to be played any time the Federal government wishes to legislate, seems to be a usurpation of rights reserved to the States.  Thoughtful people can hold either view.

Reading the pleadings, the briefs, the opinions, is interesting perhaps for lawyers.  We were trained to think that issues like these should be resolved based on reason and the rule of law.  But the loud and angry mob on both sides of this debate will insist that the only correct result is the one they have emotionally invested in ... and no matter which way the case is decided, there will be a mob to launch personal attacks on the judges who make the decision.   And I know many lawyers who are more comfortable in the mob than in the legal arguments.  A sad commentary on the tenor of our public debate, where we have largely lost the capacity for civil discourse, and respect for our government and its institutions.  We are poorer as a result.  

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Estate Planning: Having the Conversation

When I was first practicing law in the 1980's, the term "estate planning" conjured up visions of lawyers in expensive suits and large offices sitting down with the DuPonts and the Pews and figuring out ways to keep their fortunes intact through the next ten generations. Estate planning meant avoiding taxes through intricate schemes and legal gymnastics that most of the people I knew didn't need. Today [now 2020 - ed.], the federal estate tax only applies to estates over $11.58 million per person. Only the wealthiest 2% of the population needs to be concerned with planning for federal taxes. But I have lived more life since then, I have seen loved ones become ill and pass away, and I have gone to their homes and sorted through their things, and discovered more about what estate planning really means. It is about planning, about organizing, about confronting your own mortality, and most of all about having "the Conversation".

People shy away from thinking and talking about the various events of life that can change their day to day routine so quickly: about accidents, illness and disease, aging and death. They are events that we cannot control, but they are events that we can plan for. Having the conversation starts with talking to yourself: what is your contingency plan if you are hospitalized, if you have a lingering illness, if you cannot make your wishes known to your doctors and loved ones. Who do you want to make those decisions when you can't?

The law is its infinite wisdom provides the method for all of the people who do not plan for these events. If you cannot take care of yourself, the law permits a guardian to be appointed, in a process involving lawyers, a judge, hearings, time and expense. If you have not made your wishes known through a living will, then the law provides the same process: lawyers, a judge, hearings, perhaps Congressional hearings and political battles as well, all to determine what you might have decided if you had been competent to decide the issue of your own life and death. A little thoughtful planning, a discussion with your family, a little expense, and you can provide for these situations, you can decide the issues that only you should really decide, you can document them, and then you have done all you can. You have bought a relatively inexpensive form of insurance for the situation. But most important, you have had the conversation, first with yourself, and then with your loved ones. You have made a plan.

Estate planning today means having a durable financial power of attorney that designates one or more trusted loved ones to take charge of your financial affairs when you are unable to do so. It means having a living will - also called a medical directive - that expresses what you would want done if you are in an end-stage medical condition, and selecting the person or people who you want making those decisions when you can't. It means having a will that provides for your loved ones and appoints the person you want to handle your affairs. It means considering making gifts while you can enjoy the giving; checking to make sure your insurance beneficiary designations are up to date; putting your records together in one safe place, writing notes to explain your affairs, and even attending to your genealogy, and putting the names of the people on the back of the old family pictures. It means telling your loved ones that you love them, writing them letters to be opened when you are gone, and showing them how much you love them by the thoughtful way in which you have prepared for that day.

By having the conversation, first with yourself, and then with your loved ones, and then putting an estate plan in place, you do not ward off the events of life, but you have done everything in your power to prepare for them. So start today, in the morning over coffee or tea, and have the conversation.

first published: (2-21-08)  *  last revised 5-1-2020  *  ©2008 Douglas P. Humes


Doug Humes has been a practicing attorney in Pennsylvania since 1980.  He has experience in real estate, community, corporate and small business law, and estate planning.  In 2003, he opened his private general practice at the Millridge Manor House in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania.  You can contact him at Tel: 610-525-7150, or via email at humeslaw@verizon.net).

Friday, February 5, 2010

On the Shoulders of Giants: Direct Debit of HOA/Condo Assessments - Can it be done; should it be done; how is it done?

[I belong to various mailing lists, where other lawyers from different specialties gather to discuss issues and how they handle them in their practices.  I have made a habit of copying the particularly useful suggestions, comments, and forms that are submitted in these lists into my personal collection of forms and commentary that constitutes my electronic law library.  Now that I have started blogging, I am going to pass along items that I believe may be helpful to clients and other practitioners in these areas.  I don't claim any originality in these postings - they are basically a compilation of the good ideas of others - using my language and editing.  I am therefore standing on the "Shoulders of Giants" when I do so.]

I have had landlords who have negotiated into their leases the concept of having direct debit from the tenant's account for monthly rent.  Creditors love this idea - the money comes on time, without float, without excuses.  Most of us are over the fear of some horrible Big Brother type assault on our finances when it is done by computer rather than by check.  We (most of us) are comfortable with online banking.  We pay some of our bills and utilities this way.  So why not extend the idea to HOA and Condominium assessments? 

Can a Board require this, to the exclusion of any other payment method?  Probably not right now.  There are people who don't have computers, don't have the software, don't bank online, or don't have the confidence in electronic payments.  They will always need to have an alternative available for them.  However, in light of the convenience and time saving of the electronic debit, could a board offer a discount to those who would agree to electronic debit payments?  Yes, I think so.  Just as sending out paper bills, with stamps, which someone must create, stuff, lick, and post, is labor intensive, so is opening the envelope, stamping the check, doing the math, putting them together with a deposit slip, and making the deposit to the bank.   With a pre-authorized monthly or quarterly debit, the transaction happens while we are going about our other business.  It saves effort, and so should result in some savings that justifies giving a discount.  Who can complain?  If you have been to a public meeting, in these situations everyone can and often does complain.  However, if they have the same right as everyone else to pay electronically, like cash or credit at the pump, then your objectors should be few, particularly if you can show actual savings to the Association. 

Must the Board undertake this change by the more laborious amendment of the bylaws, or can this be done by adoption of a rule?  Most list mates seem to think that it can be done by rule adopted by the Board.  Your mileage may vary - depending upon your state, your association's articles or bylaws.  Always check your state law, and then your governing documents, to make sure there is nothing that can trip you up.  And if you want to propose doing this, do your homework, quantify the savings, check with your bank on any other fees, so that when you present the idea, you have fully considered the pros and cons.  If you have already done the math and double checked it, it should sell itself.  

Saturday, January 30, 2010

Small Claims Court in Pennsylvania


Most religions are in agreement that we should all love our neighbor, but occasionally we find that in the midst of conflict, the only way to resolve a dispute is to sue our neighbor.  There are times when people feel they cannot walk away from a dispute and must take a principled stand.  The court system since time immemorial, serves as the place to go to settle issues that cannot be resolved by the parties themselves.  That is one part of the lawyer's industry - conflict resolution.  But if for every dispute you had to each hire a lawyer and go through a lengthy procedure - the full blown trial process in the county common pleas court, then for smaller matters (smaller in dollar value, not emotional value), there would be no effective method to bring it to a head and resolve it once and for all.  The parties might be tempted to take the matter into their own hands.  Chaos ensues.  The small claims process was created for that situation. 

In Pennsylvania (outside of Philadelphia, where a slightly different system exists), claims of $8,000 or less may be resolved by the lowest level of the court system, a single district justice in a township office.  The District Justice has limited jurisdiction:  he or she can hear summary offenses (like traffic tickets), landlord-tenant claims, contract and certain other civil claims that don't exceed $8000, as well as handling a variety of criminal matters.  You must file your claim with the District Justice office where either the claim occurred, or where the defendant lives.  The paperwork is simple:  a one page form, available from the District Justice's office or online, where the plaintiff is asked to briefly describe his or her claim.  The filing fee is about $56 at last check.  Once the complaint is filed with the court, it sets a hearing 30-60 days out, and then serves the defendant with a copy of the complaint and asks them to file a written answer.  If the defendant responds and shows up at the hearing, then the matter continues.  If the defendant is served but does not show up, then he or she loses by default and a judgment is entered.  If the defendant is not served, the hearing is delayed until the defendant can be served. 

At the hearing, the procedure is simplified:  the claimant is asked to tell his or her case; and let any witnesses testify to what they saw or heard.  When the plaintiff is done, then the defendant presents witnesses and can choose to testify as to why he or she should not be found liable to pay the claimant.  Each side can cross examine the witnesses from the other side.  Typically the District Justice may ask questions as well, to try to narrow the focus to just the legal issues that he or she must decide.    When each party has had their say, the District Justice will thank the parties and send them on their way with the promise of a decision within several days.  The District Justice decides the case, based on the evidence presented at the hearing, and puts the decision (but not the reasons)  on a one page form that shows who won, and how much.  A winning claimant also is entitled to the filing fees and service fees they have paid out.  This decision is promptly mailed out within a few days of the hearing.  A small claim can therefore be filed, heard and decided within a 60 day period.  That is one of its main virtues - the parties have aired their differences and an independent third party had heard both sides and made a binding decision. 

Each party is entitled to bring an attorney; but at the low end of these types of claims, unless your cousin Vinnie is a lawyer and owes you a favor, it may not be cost effective to hire a lawyer and pay them to prepare the case and attend the hearing and do any necessary follow up.  That's another one of the virtues of the small claims process - you do not need a lawyer.  One or both of you can show up without a lawyer (though if one party is a corporation, then they must be represented either by their officers or a lawyer). 

The end game:  if you win, you get a judgment - a legally enforceable order to pay a specific amount.  If the defendant does not voluntarily pay, then the claimant must have the sheriff go out to the defendant's home and levy on personal property in order to sell it and pay the judgment.  Also, the defendant can appeal the decision within thirty days of entry of the judgment, but that typically requires hiring an attorney to file the necessary paperwork and begin to navigate through the much more complex procedure of a trial court.  If an appeal is timely made, then the next trial is "de novo" - nothing that happened at the District Justice office matters.  There is simply a new trial.  

Having attended an arbitration hearing today, and seen parties representing themselves, here are some recommendations if you will go to small claims court without an attorney: 

            1.  Prepare in advance.  If you find yourself involved in any dispute, it is a good idea to begin making your record - keep track of each conversation, and what each party said - buy a small notebook to keep it organized in one place.  Make a paper trail:  either dated notes, or a follow up letter saying "as we discussed on January 29, 2010, you said you would pay me the $50 you owe me by next week."  A year later, your testimony as to exact dates and times and conversation and specific letters that went unanswered will be more persuasive.

            2.  Arrive on time:  if you are not there when the case is called, you lose. 

            3.  Look your best, and present your case in an organized way.  Usually, a chronological account of what happened is best for most claims.  Have copies of each document you want to present - a copy for the judge, one for the other party and one for you.  Have the original document with you to be able to show to the judge. 

            4.  For each item of damages you claim, you need to prove it:  a witness, a written receipt, a phone record or other writing.  Written proof is more persuasive than a year old hazy memory. 

            5.  Be polite and civil.  To the judge, to your witnesses, to the other party and their witnesses.  It's simply good manners.

When you are in conflict with another, you may always choose to turn the other cheek, but if you find that you must stand on principle, or must right a wrong done to you, then for those claims below the dollar threshold, the doors of justice are open to you to quickly and inexpensively have your day in court.

©2010  Douglas P. Humes